making an exception and deleting the old stealth-updated file

Mojca Miklavec mojca at macports.org
Fri Jan 10 11:32:43 PST 2014


Hi,

a long time ago (in 2011) a Geant4 data file has been stealth-updated
(see http://trac.macports.org/ticket/32320). Apparently there was no
change.

Now this file is still being used in the latest Geant4 10.0 (I find it
weird, but it wasn't used in 9.6 and it hasn't been updated in
contrast to the rest) and it is causing me headaches due to the way I
tried to simplify the port.

I'm currently specifying the data files this way:

set geant.data_versions_10.0 {
  G4NDL              4.4   checksums
  G4EMLOW            6.35  checksums
  PhotonEvaporation  3.0   checksums
  RadioactiveDecay   4.0   checksums
  G4NEUTRONXS        1.4   checksums
  G4PII              1.3   checksums
  RealSurface        1.0   checksums
  G4SAIDDATA         1.1   checksums
  G4ABLA             3.0   checksums
  G4ENSDFSTATE       1.0   checksums
}

and I find it painful and ugly to try to make sure that one specific
54K file from the list (G4ABLA.3.0.tar.gz) must be fetched from
https://distfiles.macports.org/geant4/.

I cannot easily change ${dist_subdir} because that would mean that
lots of data files that already exist would need to be fetched again
and stored to a second location.

Would it be possible to make just a tiny single-time exception and
remove the old G4ABLA.3.0.tar.gz from
https://distfiles.macports.org/geant4/ and the buildbots? I would be
enormously grateful for that and I'm willing to support any user
running into the problem and ask him/her to delete the old file. I'm
guessing the the userbase for geant4 must be small anyway and many
users need to install fresh when they upgrade the computers anyway.

Now that I look back the port for geant4.9.5-data is actually already
broken and can only be installed as a binary package (I fixed the
checksums only after noticing a build failure on the buildbot,
http://trac.macports.org/changeset/111740/trunk/dports/science/geant4/Portfile).
Installing it from source should fail. I would need this change
primarily for a *new* port geant4.10.0-data, so it's not like users
will run into the problem on a daily basis either. I don't plan to
revbump or upgrade geant4.9.5-data which also depends on this file.

Thank you very much,
    Mojca


More information about the macports-dev mailing list