[MacPorts] #18632: Finding perl ports that are part of other ports is too hard

[MacPorts]

#18632: Finding perl ports that are part of other ports is too hard
----------------------+--------------------------------
  Reporter:  scott@…  |      Owner:  macports-tickets@…
      Type:  defect   |     Status:  new
  Priority:  Normal   |  Milestone:
 Component:  ports    |    Version:  1.7.0
Resolution:           |   Keywords:
      Port:           |
----------------------+--------------------------------
Description changed by ryandesign@…:

Old description:

> I love MacPorts, it makes my life easier, sometimes, it makes my life
> harder.  What is the solution to solve this?
>
> Example Case:
> port search p5-Tie-RDBM
> No match for p5-Tie-RDBM found
>
> Search MacPorts
> http://www.macports.org/ports.php?by=name&substr=rdbm
> Nothing
>
> Search CPAN
> http://search.cpan.org/~lds/Tie-DBI-1.02/lib/Tie/RDBM.pm
> Finds it with no issue
>
> Now I am stuck, do I make a port for it?  I did, I think I wasted my
> time.
>
> port search p5-Tie-DBI
> p5-tie-dbi @1.02 (perl)
>     Nie:DBI This distribution contains Tie::DBI and Tie::RDBM
>
> I do not really know what to suggest, I brought it up on the mail list a
> while back.  There was opposition to adding more data to the portfile,
> opposition to my suggestion to add another field for the purpose of
> listing ports that contain other ports.
>
> At this point, I would at least suggest, that in cases like this, some
> "stub" record be added to the web based port search.  Ideally, it should
> all be handled in the ports on the command line.
>
> CPAN makes me want to barf, almost all the time, CPAN wins in this case,
> as it finds what I need, on the web, or in the command line.

New description:

 I love MacPorts, it makes my life easier, sometimes, it makes my life
 harder.  What is the solution to solve this?

 Example Case:
 {{{
 port search p5-Tie-RDBM
 No match for p5-Tie-RDBM found
 }}}

 Search MacPorts [[br]]
 http://www.macports.org/ports.php?by=name&substr=rdbm [[br]]
 Nothing

 Search CPAN [[br]]
 http://search.cpan.org/~lds/Tie-DBI-1.02/lib/Tie/RDBM.pm [[br]]
 Finds it with no issue

 Now I am stuck, do I make a port for it?  I did, I think I wasted my time.

 {{{
 port search p5-Tie-DBI
 p5-tie-dbi @1.02 (perl)
     Nie:DBI This distribution contains Tie::DBI and Tie::RDBM
 }}}

 I do not really know what to suggest, I brought it up on the mail list a
 while back.  There was opposition to adding more data to the portfile,
 opposition to my suggestion to add another field for the purpose of
 listing ports that contain other ports.

 At this point, I would at least suggest, that in cases like this, some
 "stub" record be added to the web based port search.  Ideally, it should
 all be handled in the ports on the command line.

 CPAN makes me want to barf, almost all the time, CPAN wins in this case,
 as it finds what I need, on the web, or in the command line.

--

-- 
Ticket URL: <https://trac.macports.org/ticket/18632#comment:3>
MacPorts <http://www.macports.org/>
Ports system for OS X